It’s officially barbecue rib season, and I couldn’t be more excited. I have made them three times in the last week and I am planning on making them for a party this weekend.
I might be a little rib obsessed – it is an occupational hazard of barbecuing for a living. But I don’t know many people who can turn down a bone or two or three. My rib-awakening happened at the world’s largest barbecue contest – Memphis in May. All it took was that first bite of a grill-smoked rib for me to realize real barbecued ribs very rarely come out of a restaurant kitchen. They are usually much better made and enjoyed in your own backyard.
There is nothing like homemade ribs. And, once you get over the intimidation factor, you realize they don’t take nearly as long to cook as barbecue myth has it, and they also are very easy to prepare.
The most popular ribs to cook are back ribs, but spareribs and St. Louis-style ribs are becoming more and more popular. This week, I cooked a slab of back ribs, a slab of spare ribs and a slab of St. Louis to see which ones I liked better. Not surprisingly, they were all good. I re-discovered it’s important to look at the ribs in the store and choose them based on the way they look more than the cut. They should be plump, heavy for their size and have some visible fat. The fat will render out during the cooking time, leaving flavor and help create a nice crust on the ribs. These days pork can be so lean you don’t see a lot of fat, even on the ribs.
In case you aren’t familiar with the difference between the three cuts, here is a primer:
• Back ribs are cut from high up on the rib near the spinal column. Back ribs are meaty, leaner than spareribs and very flavorful – this is the area of the pig that “produces” the tenderloin. Back ribs usually are sold in either full slabs (13 ribs). But you may find them in half slabs (7 ribs) since they are the most expensive cut of rib, some stores cut the rack in half so the single item appears less expensive. When they come from a pig that is less than a year old, they are referred to as “baby” back ribs. True baby back ribs generally weigh around 1 to 1½ pounds each, which makes them difficult to cook on the grill because they have so little meat on their bones.
• Spareribs are cut from the belly or side of the pig. Spareribs are longer and fattier than back ribs. While they have less meat, many parts of the country prefer them and they also are a bargain. I paid about $2.50 a pound for a full slab of spareribs and the back ribs were nearly $10 a pound.
• The St. Louis cut is a sparerib trimmed to remove the flap of meat on the underside of the breast bone and squared off to more easily fit on the grill. The St. Louis-style cut is becoming more popular with restaurants, backyard barbecuers and the barbecue circuit.
Once you decide on which rib to buy, there are a few things to remember when buying your meat. Number one: Make sure each slab weighs close to 2 pounds each, and that the ribs have a nice layer of meat covering the bone. Slabs of ribs that are factory-cut often have “bone shine” or areas of the rack where the blade hit the bone and cut off all the meat exposing the bone.
And, it goes without saying you need to buy the best quality, freshest product available. This is especially true with meat and there is a wide range of product in the marketplace. Plan on buying half a rack per person, more if you are serving big eaters. I always round up one rack; for example, if I am serving 7 to 8 people, I buy 5 racks of ribs. After taking the time to make the ribs, you don’t want to run out.
If you have a local butcher who cuts the meat, frequent his or her shop. He’ll give you tips on cooking, can cut meat to order and can special order meat, as well.
If you don’t have a local butcher, go to a grocery store that has high traffic and keeps the meat case rotated with fresh product every day. Beyond that, be sure to look at the expiration date on the label and give what you are buying the old-fashioned smell test. If it smells “off” or a little funny, then it is probably old. I prefer buying ribs that are cryovac-ed as they are generally the freshest choice.
The next decision you have to make is whether or not to remove the silver skin. Along the back (non-meaty) side of a slab of ribs there is a smooth covering or membrane that holds the ribs together. It is often referred to as the silver skin. Some people recommend removing it, but it is purely optional whether you take it off or not. If you leave it on, it is a good indicator of when the ribs are done because it lifts away from the meat when the meat is cooked. It is very crispy when done and looks a little like parchment paper and is slightly translucent.
Many people consider it a delicacy and really like eating it, and many more don’t even know it is removable. A few cooks say leaving the membrane intact prevents the seasoning from penetrating the meat and stops the rendering of the fat. I have never found this to be true, I think it is mostly a cosmetic issue and a little known one at that. Be forewarned, if your rack of ribs has any “bone shine,” the membrane will keep the rack intact and if you remove it, your rack will likely fall apart.
The final thing you need to know is the best way to test for doneness is to make sure the meat has receded from the end of the bones and you can bend the rack without breaking it in pieces. And, remember the only way the meat will fall off the bone, is if you par-boil them first (just say no!) or if you over-cook them. The best ribs should be tender but have a little “chew” left.
Backyard Ribs 101
Servings: 6 to 8
Start to finish: 4 hours
This recipe is my version of ribs that made me fall in love with backyard ribs. The Memphis in May barbecue team took me under their wing and shared their secret – slathering the ribs in fresh lemon juice before seasoning them.
4 racks pork ribs, about 2 to 3 pounds a slab
2 lemons, cut in half
1/4 cup Classic Barbecue Rub (see below) or favorite spice rub
Soaked wood chips, if desired
Favorite barbecue sauce
Build charcoal fire or preheat gas grill. Remove silver skin from back of ribs, if desired. I prefer to leave it on the ribs.
Set up the grill for indirect heat and if using wood chips, place soaked chips directly on charcoal, or in smoking box of gas grill. Rub the cut lemons over front and back of ribs squeezing to release as much juice as possible. Discard any lemon seeds. Set aside for 5 minutes. Sprinkle ribs liberally with spice rub and let sit, covered, for 15 minutes.
Place ribs (bone side down) in the center of the cooking grate or in a rib holder/rack, making sure they are not over a direct flame. Grill covered (at about 300 degrees F., if your grill has a thermometer) for 2 to 3 hours, depending on how big your racks are.
Two-pound racks will take about 2 hours and 3-pound racks will take closer to 3 hours. The meat will be tender, and you can see that it has pulled back (receded) from the ends of the rib bones. Leave ribs untended for the first 30 minutes – this means no peeking; especially important if using wood chips. If the ribs start to burn on the edges, stack them on top of one another in the very center of the grill and lower your fire/heat slightly.
Twenty minutes before serving, un-stack ribs, if necessary, and brush with barbecue sauce. Remove ribs from grill and let rest 10 minutes before cutting into individual or 2 to 3 rib portions.
Warm remaining sauce in a saucepan and serve on the side, if desired.
Backyard Rib Rub
Makes about 1½ cups
3 tablespoons white granulated sugar
2 tablespoons smoked paprika
2 tablespoons kosher salt
2 tablespoons dark brown sugar
1 tablespoon ground cumin
1 tablespoon freshly ground Worcestershire black pepper
1 tablespoon onion powder
1 tablespoon garlic powder
2 teaspoons chili powder
1/2 teaspoon cayenne pepper
In a medium bowl, combine all the ingredients; mix well. For a smoother rub, process the ingredients in a spice grinder until well combined and all the pieces are uniform (the rub will be become a very fine powder and tan in color. It can be stored in an airtight container for up to 6 months.)
• Nutrition information per serving: 221 calories; 115 calories from fat; 13 g fat (4 g saturated; 0 g trans fats); 72 mg cholesterol; 627 mg sodium; 5 g carbohydrate; 0 g fiber; 3 g sugar; 22 g protein
EDITOR’S NOTE: Elizabeth Karmel is a barbecue and Southern foods expert. She is the chef and pit master at online retailer CarolinaCueToGo.com and the author of three books, including “Taming the Flame.”